Wind farms and coal mines both change landscapes. A fair comparison looks beyond appearance to land use, environmental impacts and the economics of energy. In Australia, wind turbines can attract fierce criticism for changing rural views. Yet coal mines, gas fields and other infrastructure that supply our existing energy system also leave lasting marks on the landscape. The language used to describe these projects can be revealing. Critics describe turbines as industrialising the countryside or scarring the horizon. Those concerns deserve attention, as do the visible consequences of coal extraction. Open-cut coal mines, with their excavated landscapes, waste rock, dust, haul roads and heavy machinery, are often discussed in terms…Continued →